Whisky in Isolation The Joy of Six Whisky Review!

An independent bottling of Australian single malt from one of our newest. High strength, natural presentation, relatively reasonable pricing, different and/or unusual cask treatments to the official bottlings, and highlighting lesser-known distilleries. Which should be independent bottling 101!

Like the name suggests and like many passion projects, Whisky In Isolation was born of the pandemic. Deep in the throes of lockdowns and isolation in early 2020, Melbourne-based proprietor Justin Farmer was inspired & encouraged by his wife to pursue his passion for whisky in earnest. That initially began with a blog under the Whisky in Isolation name, but soon blossomed into filling casks with spirit from various distilleries, experimenting with different finishes on maturing whisky, and playing around with vatting / blending casks of mature whiskies. The first Whisky In Isolation bottling titled "Nearly New York Sour" (in homage to the cocktail) was released in mid-2022, and there have been another three releases since. The subsequent releases have been sourced from VIC's Kinglake Distillery, Tasmania's Hobart Whisky / Devil's Distillery, and now Victoria's Chief's Son Distillery. Four releases in under 12-months is not a bad run for such a tiny operation, and the plan is to stick to similar volumes for the foreseeable future - meaning, all going well, there should be another three releases coming in the remainder of 2023. Justin has partnered with a number of small distilleries for future releases, both in Tasmania and on the Australian mainland, with a simple but effective goal in mind: "just great whisky". All bottlings to date have been around the same relatively reasonable price point, which has helped Justin gather quite the following in such a short period of time. 

This fourth release from Whisky In Isolation is from Chief's Son Distillery, a small operation located on the Mornington Peninsula in Victoria, around an hour's drive south-east of Melbourne. Chief's Son was founded by husband & wife team Stuart & Naomi McIntosh back in 2013, which practically makes them middle-aged in terms of the continuing (for now) boom in Australian distilleries. Chief's Son single malts are double distilled in a single copper pot still that is heated by an internal electric element, which is quite a common thing in Australian whisky production despite the extra manual labour that it involves. Stills don't come cheap, after all! Another common thing in Australian whisky production is the sourcing of wash from local breweries rather than brewing / fermenting on site, which is a cost-cutting, risk-reducing, and time-saving measure that would not be legally permitted if we were in Scotland. You could argue that doing this also helps with consistency, but my counter-argument is that that's a negative rather than a positive. You're effectively losing a large chunk of individuality and potentially personality in the finished product, particularly if multiple distilleries are using the same brewery and the same specifications. Even some of the biggest names in the industry take advantage of this method (some would say "loophole"), and Chief's Son are no exception. They do take it a step further though by specifying a number of different types of brewer's malts, or at least different specialty roasting levels, in their mash bills. These range from pale malt to crystal (think Benromach Cara Gold) and chocolate malt (think Glenmorangie Signet), while small amounts of peated malted barley are sourced from Scotland.  

The Whisky In Isolation bottling that we're looking at today is the oldest Chief's Son whisky bottled to date, at 6-years and 6-months of age. That may sound young on a global scale - probably because it is young on a global scale - but that's almost middle-aged by Australian whisky standards where many releases are only aged for the legal minimum of 2-years before they're pushed out the door. New expression The Joy of Six has been fully matured in small format first-fill French oak ex-apera fortified wine casks that were sourced from the Barossa Valley in South Australia. Apera is basically our take on a Spanish sherry, generally approximating an Oloroso style, although they tend to be lighter in style than you might expect from a traditional Oloroso sherry. Being first-fill and small format French oak casks though, I'm sure there's going to be plenty of both fortified influence and wood influence here. Small format casks in Australian whisky generally means 20-litre or 50-litre casks, or somewhere in between. These tiny casks combined with our warm and highly variable climate can wreak havoc on maturing spirit, particularly given the aggressive nature of French oak that is the most commonly used species in our industry - which is essentially dictated by the local table & fortified wine industries who have the first go at the casks before selling them on. The saving grace in this case is blending (a.k.a. vatting, still a single malt) these small casks of Chief's Son whisky together, playing around with the flavour profile, and also adjusting the ABV for the best results. In this case a few 20-litre casks were vatted together, and the ABV was reduced slightly to 54.25% because that's where Justin felt this whisky was at its best. It is of course non-chill filtered and natural colour, and retails here for $195 AUD in a 500ml bottle, with a tiny outturn of 105 bottles. As mentioned above, that's a perfectly reasonable price in Australia compared to much of the competition - both in independent and official bottlings - particularly at this age and ABV. 

For those familiar with Australian whisky, I know what you'll be thinking here, particularly if you've spied the colour below. "20-litre first-fill fortified wine casks for 6.5-years in Australia, so we're probably in for another overly sweet, overly wood-driven whisky, right?" Well I wouldn't be so hasty, since those specialty malts used at Chief's Son seem to balance out the impact of the fortified wine casks, and also because Justin has selected and vatted these particular casks for a reason. The bottle of The Joy of Six for this review was kindly donated by Justin, with no strings attached. So let's see how it goes, shall we? 

Whisky in Isolation "The Joy of Six", 6-years old, 54.25% ABV. Victoria, Australia.

Distilled at Chief's Son Distillery in Somerville, Victoria. Vatting of 2 x 20-litre first-fill ex-Apera (sherry style fortified wine) casks. Non-chill filtered, natural colour. 105 bottles. 

Colour: Polished dark brown. 

Nose: Sweet, woody, toasty. Treacle, sultanas, sweetened ginger, and soft liquorice. Lightly burnt toast, bitter orange peel, and fresh Christmas pudding with the skin on. Even a flicker of marzipan and rich buttercream icing. Well-toasted oak, milky coffee with a dash of vanilla syrup, and soft leather. 

Texture: Medium weight. Syrupy in texture but less sweet than the nose, more toasty & roasty. Warming, no heat at all. 

Taste: More treacle, sweetened ginger, bitter orange peel, and toasted oak. Currants rather than sultanas here, and coffee froth/foam rather than syrup. That buttercream icing and soft old leather again, with some ginger toffee fudge. 

Finish: Medium length. Ginger again, spent coffee grounds, sweet toasted oak, and cinnamon. Ginger porter (dark ale) too. That soft old leather shows again, plus a little oily wood polish, and toffee fudge. Turning slightly astringent towards the end with tea leaves  - that'll be the tannins showing themselves, without going too far. 

Score: 3.5 out of 5. Not too far from a 4, in fact. 

Notes: Lovely complexity for a relatively young whisky that has been matured in small first-fill casks, which is a surprise. There are still shades of the Chief's Son official bottlings in places, but this independent certainly seems more rounded and more mature in comparison - which makes sense, since this is the oldest Chief's Son bottled to date. The sweetness and wood influence are both immediately obvious, but they're actually well balanced and measured, neither is allowed to steal the show. The tannins that we expect from small French oak casks don't show up until late in the finish, and they don't get into the full bitterness that many similarly-aged whiskies do. Which is a very good thing. Those ginger & fudgy notes are delicious as well. Makes for a great winter warmer!

This is still a very "Aussie" style whisky of course, in terms of sweetness and wood influence. But it's on the great quality end of the spectrum that isn't all about raw oak and using overly sweet fortified wine or other shenanigans to hide an undercooked whisky. Think modern Heartwood, Highwayman, Iniquity, Launceston, that sort of thing. Add the extremely competitive pricing at this age and ABV, and you're onto a winner. This is my first Whisky in Isolation bottling, and it's very impressive stuff. Already looking forward to the next one!

Thanks to Justin for the bottle for this review. It'll be thoroughly enjoyed and widely shared!

Cheers!